• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Tony's Pizza - Buffalo: Your Ultimate Late-Night Snack Destination

Tony's Pizza - Buffalo is a cherished gem located at 3680 Harlem Rd, Buffalo, NY. Renowned for its fast service and reasonable prices, it has earned the loyalty of local patrons, including those who have ordered weekly for over a decade. Not only do they serve outstanding pizza, but their menu also features beloved options like crispy wings and mouthwatering subs. Customers rave about the quality and flavors, with many recalling fond childhood memories associated with the restaurant. Tony's embodies the essence of an old-school pickup spot, delivering delicious, satisfying meals that keep diners coming back for more.

Tony's Pizza - Buffalo: Reviews & Ratings

heather gurman
heather gurman

awesome folks, fast great food and reasonably priced our boss has been ordering & every Tuesday for over 10yrs. serious food dedication indeed! thanku all of you !!

Leopard Cleopatra
Leopard Cleopatra

5/5 experience; Sub was banging…, I had the stinger with honey garlic sauce, fries were crispy with a side of extra honey garlic and BBQ. First time trying and first time making a review for a pizzeria. Found them by looking up on google for a late night snack and everything lately in WNY closes early. Knowing this place was open late made me want to try them and I’ll definitely will be ordering again! Never tried their pizza but if their subs are this good for a review then I’m sure their pizza is too. P.S., fried dough is good too and not over cooked, over buttered or anything. Was made to perfection honestly. I’m picky when it comes to pizza joints but this was a place I was missing in my childhood living here in buffalo.

Joseph Ciesielski
Joseph Ciesielski

This has been my place since childhood! Just returned to Buffalo and still quality! The wings have been incredible to good both times I got them! (20-25 minutes drive back home), pizza has been perfect, and always quick and easy! Looks old and dingy! But this is an old school pickup place! Can’t beat it!

Mariangela Mercurio
Mariangela Mercurio

I got the Greek wrap it was quite delicious and honestly bigger than I anticipated, chicken was cooked to perfection, it was very fast service as well

Location

Welcome to the heart of Buffalo, where a culinary gem awaits: Tony's Pizza - Buffalo. Nestled at 3680 Harlem Rd, this restaurant has become a beloved staple among locals and visitors alike. With a commitment to quality and customer satisfaction, Tony's stands out as a haven for late-night cravings and nostalgic flavors.

Customer experiences at Tony's Pizza reflect a deep appreciation for both the food and the folks behind the counter. As one satisfied customer, Heather Gurman, notes, "awesome folks, fast great food and reasonably priced" showcases the team's dedication. With over ten years of consistent weekly orders from local businesses, it's clear that Tony's has earned a loyal following.

Not just a pizzeria, Tony's offers a variety of dishes that tantalize the taste buds. From the positive review of Leopard Cleopatra, who savored the "banging" Stinger sub, it’s evident that the culinary offerings extend beyond just pizza. The crispy fries paired with honey garlic sauce are a highlight, alongside the much-praised fried dough cooked to perfection. The mention of sub sandwiches piques curiosity about the pizza, as it hints at the overall quality and dedication to their craft.

For those who have cherished their childhood memories, like Joseph Ciesielski, returning to Tony's is a trip down memory lane. The consistent quality of the wings and pizza keeps patrons coming back for more, creating a familiar and comforting dining experience. Despite the old-school charm of the establishment, which some may find "dingy," it is this character that adds to the authenticity of Tony’s Pizza - a place where the past meets present in a delicious blend.

With quick service and sizable portions, customers like Mariangela Mercurio rave about the Greek wrap—a dish that exemplifies Tony's culinary excellence. The perfectly cooked chicken and swift service create an ideal dining experience, whether you're grabbing a bite on the go or settling in for a comforting meal.

If you're in Buffalo, a visit to Tony's Pizza is a must. Whether you come for the pizza, the subs, or the stellar wings, you’ll find a warmth that only an establishment with a rich history can provide. What truly sets Tony’s Pizza apart is not just the food but the feeling you get when you walk through its doors—one of belonging and of shared appreciation for delicious food done right.

So, next time you’re searching for a late-night meal or a nostalgic taste of Buffalo, remember: Tony's Pizza - Buffalo is waiting for you with open arms and a menu full of delights.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Has wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
  • Service options
    • Offers delivery
    • Offers takeaway
    • Serves dine-in
  • Payments
    • Accepts debit cards
    • Accepts NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards